Band 9 model answer
A model answer written to illustrate a Band 9 response to this question, with the rubric breakdown and what carries it. Written by us as a teaching example, not a verified exam script.
“Some companies are exploring drone delivery for online shopping. What are the advantages and disadvantages?”9
Overall
9
Task response
9
Coherence & cohesion
8
Lexical resource
9
Grammar
A number of companies are now experimenting with delivering online purchases by drone rather than by road. This development brings clear benefits but also raises significant problems, both of which deserve consideration.
The advantages are mainly speed and efficiency. Drones can travel in a straight line, unaffected by traffic congestion, so parcels, including urgent items such as medicines or blood for hospitals, could reach customers within minutes rather than days. Because they are electric and bypass road networks, drones could also cut the fuel use and emissions associated with conventional delivery vans, and reach remote or rural communities that are slow and expensive to serve by truck. For businesses, lower delivery costs and faster service would be a considerable competitive advantage.
The disadvantages, however, are not trivial. Large numbers of drones flying over towns and cities raise serious concerns about safety, since a malfunction could send a heavy machine crashing onto the people below, and about privacy, as airborne cameras pass over homes and gardens. The constant buzzing of delivery drones would add a new and intrusive form of noise pollution to urban life, and the technology could displace the many workers currently employed in delivery. Airspace would also need careful regulation to prevent mid-air collisions.
In conclusion, drone delivery promises faster, cleaner, and more far-reaching service, but it also brings real risks to safety, privacy, and employment, along with the practical challenge of managing increasingly crowded skies. Whether it becomes widespread will depend on how effectively these drawbacks can be controlled.
- •Fully addresses a balanced “advantages and disadvantages” task, giving each side a developed paragraph.
- •Ideas are concrete: medicine and blood delivery, rural reach, noise pollution, airspace regulation.
- •Accurate, varied vocabulary: “traffic congestion”, “noise pollution”, “displace … workers”, “mid-air collisions”.
- •Clear organisation and confident control of complex sentences throughout.
- •The task does not require a stance, but a brief closing judgement on the balance would round it off.
Write your own. Get a real band read.
Reading a model answer only takes you so far. Write your own response to this question and we’ll grade it against the four official rubrics, the same way we scored this one.
Attempt this question